Weight of the Gift: Moral Injury and Ethical Dilemmas in Clinical Care
A moderated panel exploring the ethical grey zones, systemic toll, and emotional aftermath of high-stakes clinical decisions in transplant medicine and beyond.
You need to be registered on eLecture to access this recording. Registration is free.
About This Session
Modern medicine is full of awe-inspiring breakthroughs. But behind every high-stakes intervention — whether in transplant surgery, intensive care, emergency medicine, or paediatrics — are the clinicians making impossible choices in impossible circumstances.
In this emotionally resonant and panel-driven session, Dr Heidi Matisonn, Senior Lecturer in Bioethics at the UCT EthicsLab, moderates a frank and searching discussion with leading voices across specialities: transplant surgery, nephrology, abdominal transplantation, and paediatric hepatology. Together, they explore moral injury: the deep psychological and ethical dissonance experienced when clinicians feel compelled to act in ways that violate their personal or professional code.
It is not burnout. It is not fatigue. It is something more insidious — the quiet erosion of moral clarity in systems marked by scarcity, inequity, and complexity. Through real-world stories and case reflections, this session unpacks the ethical tensions at the heart of modern healthcare: what it means to choose one patient over another, to act within flawed systems, and to live with the emotional aftermath of decisions that save some lives while letting others go.
- How do clinicians reconcile choosing one patient over another when both need life-saving intervention?
- What does it mean to uphold “first, do no harm” in situations where every option carries significant risk?
- What happens when you know the ethically right course of action — but the system won’t allow it?
- How do under-resourced hospitals and structural inequities shape clinical decisions, and who carries that weight?
- From ICU nurses and paediatricians to transplant co-ordinators and trauma surgeons — who supports the supporters?
- Why are moral injuries so often buried beneath professional stoicism and institutional silence?
- Can we create open, protected spaces for clinicians to speak honestly about moral distress — without stigma or fear?
- What role do mentorship, peer debriefing, and ethics consultations play in helping teams rebuild moral clarity?
Meet the Forum
Five voices across bioethics, surgery, nephrology, and paediatric hepatology. Click any card to read the full biography.
